Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Tennessee adoption ruling bodes ill for same-sex couple second parent adoption

Court rulings that affect same-sex couples raising children often come in the context of heterosexual families. When you think about it, that's inevitable, since there are so many more heterosexuals and they, too, live in a variety of family forms. Well, a decision from the Tennessee Court of Appeals last month, In re Shleby L.B., falls into this category, and the news is not good. (For a Colorado ruling involving heterosexuals that bodes very well for same-sex couples there, read this post from last April).

A child, Shelby L.B., was born to a married heterosexual couple in 1999. When the couple divorced two years later, the child went with her mother and the father had no visitation rights but could petition for them in the future after completing alcohol and drug rehab. The mother later became friends with a 42-year-old man, J.E.N, who began acting as a father to the child when she was five years old. In 2008, the mother and J.E.N. filed a joint petition to terminate the parental rights of the father and allow J.E.N. to adopt the child. The petition alleged that the child called J.E.N., "Dad," and that he supported her financially and spent a substantial amount of time with her forming a parent-child bond. Shortly thereafter, the mother and J.E.N. filed an amended complaint including the fact that J.E.N. had exercised physical custody of the child for substantial times and that the child was presently living with him during the school week. There is no indication that the mother and J.E.N. ever lived together or that they had a romantic relationship.

The father hired a lawyer, opposed the petition, and asked for visitation with the child. Subsequently, he filed a motion to dismiss the petition, arguing that the parental rights of both parents must be terminated before anyone other than a stepparent can adopt a child. The trial court ruled in the father's favor, and the Court of Appeals affirmed.

Here are the Tennessee laws that doomed the petition filed in this case. A biological parent cannot file a petition to terminate the rights of another parent, so the mother could not file to terminate the father's rights. That left J.E.N. He could file an adoption petition, but according to the court's interpretation of the Tennessee statute, he could only do so if he were seeking to terminate the rights of the mother as well as the father. The only exception in the statute is for a stepparent adoption, and since the mother and J.E.N. were not married, he was not the child's stepparent.

This ruling likely dooms any second parent adoption. That's because, of course, the biological parent seeks to retain, not surrender, her parental rights when her partner adopts. The only remaining possibility might be a joint petition by a same-sex couple in which the bio mom gives up her rights as a bio parent but simultaneously gets them back as an adoptive parent. A single person may adopt in Tennessee, but it is not certain that the court would say this means two single persons may adopt together.

I wish we knew more about these people. I am curious about the relationship between the mother and J.E.N. There are plenty of examples of LGBT co-parenting arrangements between other than romantic partners. Since adoption requires individualized assessment of a child's best interests, I believe these arrangements should be able to be formalized through adoption. Plus I realize that I cannot even be certain the adults in this case are heterosexual. I know the mother was once married to a man, and I know there is nothing about her sexual orientation that is reported in the opinion, but it's not impossible that her friendship with J.E.N. is not sexual because one or both of them is gay. (It is also possible the two have a sexual relationship; all we know is that they are not married to each other and they appear not to live together). So I am curious, but in the end the issue should be whether the adoption is in the child's best interests, and that is what the court refuses to address because it says such an adoption is impossible.

This case is also a reminder that when we lose second-parent adoption it is not inherently an anti-gay ruling; it may simply be a narrow reading of an adoption statute. Since adoption customarily does terminate the rights of the existing parents, statutes were written in a way that produces that result automatically. When a court reads such a statute to prohibit a parent retaining rights while adding a second parent, that may simply be reluctance to construe a statute beyond its literal wording. Of course many state courts have read their adoption statutes broadly enough to encompass second parent adoption without terminating the first parent's rights. Thank goodness for that.

3 comments:

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

asian datingWelcome to ASIANSOULMATE.COM one of the premier sites for Asian dating and other ethnicities seeking their Asian dating partner or soulmate. With a growing database of 1m Asian members and 10m global singles then there’s every chance of finding your dream partner online. Your ideal partner might be around the corner or across the oceans
gay datingWelcome to GAYSOULMATE.COM one of the premier sites for gay men seeking friendship, dating or a long-term relationship.  With one of the largest and active memberships you’ll find a wide selection of potential dates to choose from around the world and in your locality.  Is your Soulmate online? Join for free and start browsing today!
uniform datingWelcome to UniformSoulmates.com the place to find dates with forces personnel, doctors, nurses, firemen and women. Find your soulmate online today!
adult datingWelcome to AdultSoulmate.com the premier fun site for active singles. Join now and find a date today!
lesbian datingWelcome to LESBIANSOULMATES.NET the safe and secure lesbian dating site. Join thousands of like-minded singles around the globe and local to you seeking friendship, dating and long-term relationships.  Is your soulmate online today? Join for free and find out!
Interracial datingWelcome to INTERRACIALSOULMATES.COM the select site where different races, creeds and nationalities can join together for friendship, dating and serious relationships.  With over 10m Caucasian, Black, Asian and mixed race members across the globe then you have every chance of finding your ideal partner in your locality.   Perhaps your soulmate is online now?  Join for free to find out!
mature datingWelcome to MATURESOULMATES.COM the premier site for mature singles. With one of the largest dating memberships our safe and easy to use site provides the perfect opportunity for seniors 45+ in the UK, USA, South Africa, Australia and around the globe to find local sincere friends, activity partners, online dates or even that elusive soulmate.  Why not join for free today and start browsing from the comfort of your home and see if your soulmate is online today!
Senior datingWelcome to the most effective, safe online dating network connecting 45+ singles for friendship, love and marriage. Whether you are looking for a friend, activity partner, travel companion or lifetime partner you are spoiled for choice with hundreds of thousands of sincere, attractive like-minded members.

mm said...

replica louis vuitton bags for sale.
replica Mahina Leather handbags for sale.
replica louis vuitton antheia for sale.
replica Monogram Canvas for sale.
replica Monogram denim for sale.
Cheap Monogram Macassar Canvas for sale.
Replica louis vuitton monogram multicolore for sale.
replica Monogram Purses for sale.
replica Monogram Purses for sale.
replica Monogram Vernis bags for sale.




imitation louis vuitton bags for sale.
cheap louis vuitton antheia for sale.
replica Mahina Leather for sale.
replica Monogram Canvas handbags for sale.
replica Monogram denim handbags for sale.
Replica Monogram Macassar Canvas for sale.
Replica Monogram Multicolore for sale.
replica louis vuitton Monogram Vernis for sale.
replica louis vuitton Monogram Purses for sale.

Marlin said...

Regardless of sexual orientation, child adoption is a big responsibility. One does not need to be trapped in a sexual stereotype to perform the task of parents. This is where the law should state who is capable of adoption. Every interested party should prove that they are capable of raising a kid properly. In this matter, a lawyer might be able to explain the legalities and help them win the case.

Marlin Sayle